Lycaeides melissa

Geographic Range

The range of Lycaeides melissa covers the northern and western United States, portions of central and western Canada, and extends southward to northern Baja California, Mexico. They occur in the Upper Sonoran to Canadian (sometimes Alpine) Life Zones in the Nearctic region.

Karner Blues, L. melissa samuelis , historically occurred in the northern tier from New Hampshire and New York westward to Iowa. They have been extirpated from Ohio, Ontario, Maine, Illinois, Massachusetts, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania. There are remnant populations of Karner blues in Minnesota, Indiana, New York, and New Hampshire, and abundant populations in Michigan and Wisconsin.

Melissa Blues, L. melissa melissa , have the largest range of all the subspecies, occuring from Kansas to Manitoba westward throughout to northern Baja California, northern Mexico and west Texas. They have been extirpated south of the San Francisco Bay area.

Annetta Blues, L. melissa annetta , occur high in the Wasatch Mountains of Utah, the alpine Sierra Nevada, and the higher altitudes of central Colorado.

Inyo Blues, L. melissa paradoxa (also known as L. m. inyoensis ), are found in the Tehachapi Mountains in California.

• Biogeographic Regions
• nearctic nearctic
  • native native

Habitat

Karner Blues inhabit sandy pine barrens, lakeshore dunes, and sandy pine prairies that contain abundant lupine, Lupinus perinnis , their only larval foodplant. An important component of Karner Blue habitat is a heterogeneous mixture of sun and shade, and management efforts focused on improving and maintaining this habitat use fire and tree removal to facilitate this blend.

Melissa blues prefer dry ridges with tall-grass prairie biomes.

• Habitat Regions
• terrestrial terrestrial

• Terrestrial Biomes
• savanna or grassland savanna or grassland
• forest forest
• scrub forest scrub forest
• mountains mountains

Physical Description

The upper surfaces of adult male Karner Blue wings are dark blue. On adult females the blue is much reduced by a black margin. The hindwing margins have partial orange bands that border several black spots. The undersides are whitish gray with black spots, and the hindwings have small silver spots capped with orange. The fringe on the wings is black. Females forewings range in size from 1.4 cm to 1.6 cm., with the males slightly smaller, ranging from 1.2 - 1.4 cm. Melissa Blues are very similar in coloration but have a black terminal line along the vertical hindwing margins.

Karner Blue eggs have been described as very small and radially symmetrical. They are pale green in color and slightly flattened in appearance, with fine geometric patterns that are deeply reticulated.

The larvae of L. melissa have dorsally flattened bodies and are pubescent. Their head capsules are brown-black to brown and their bodies are a pea green color. As the larvae age, they develop light green to white lateral stripes and dark green dorsal stripes. Just before the larvae are ready to pupate, their color and lateral stripes begin to fade. The pupae are bright green and smooth, and just before emergence, change to a light tan color with hints of purple. Larvae have three glandular structures that secrete a liquid most likely containing carbohydrates and amino acids. This secretion is avidly harvested by ants.

• Other Physical Features
• ectothermic ectothermic
• heterothermic heterothermic
• bilateral symmetry bilateral symmetry

• Sexual Dimorphism
• female larger
• sexes colored or patterned differently

Development

Eggs oviposited by first brood females hatch in 5-10 days in early June. Larvae go through four instars and pupate in late June - early July. After emerging in early to mid July, adults will mate and the females will oviposit eggs that will overwinter. During the following spring, these larvae will hatch in April and May and begin feeding.

• Development - Life Cycle
• metamorphosis metamorphosis

Reproduction

During the daylight hours, male Karner Blues patrol near the lupines searching for females. Mating takes place primarily in open-canopied areas in the forests.

Karner Blue butterflies are bivoltine, the first brood emerging from late May to June, followed by the second brood from late July to August. The females emerge a few days later than the males. After mating, females will lay their eggs on various parts of the host plants (lupines) or on nearby sticks or pebbles. There is a difference in egg placement by first and second brood females. The majority of eggs in the first brood are placed on lupines, second brood females place the majority of their eggs on blades of grass.

• Key Reproductive Features
• semelparous semelparous
• seasonal breeding seasonal breeding
• gonochoric/gonochoristic/dioecious (sexes separate)
• sexual sexual
• fertilization fertilization
  • internal internal
• oviparous oviparous

Lepidopteran species do not provide any care for their offspring after the eggs are laid.

• Parental Investment
• pre-fertilization
  • provisioning
  • protecting
    • female

Lifespan/Longevity

Adult Karner Blues are known to live from 4-5 days up to 2-3 weeks. Total lifespan from egg through adult varies depending on the brood: eggs laid late in the season survive through winter and hatch the following year so the individuals live for about almost 12 months. Eggs laid early in May or June hatch, mature, reproduce and die in about two months.

Behavior

Karner Blues are diurnal, flying primarily from early morning to early evening. When temperatures become very hot, they decrease their activities and spend more of their time resting in shade. Heavy rains, strong winds, and temperatures below 75° F will also cause Karner Blues to spend time in protected areas. Grasses appear to be their preferred roosting sites.

Male Karner Blues fly more frequently than females, and tend to move more often and cover greater distances with their flights. Females spend more time nectaring than flying. Both sexes prefer to nectar in sunny openings in their forest habitat.

• Key Behaviors
• flies
• diurnal diurnal
• sedentary sedentary
• colonial colonial

Communication and Perception

Butterfly communication generally involves courtship flights and behaviors using visual cues. Some species are believed to emit pheremones to attract mates, but it is unknown if this true for Lycaeides melissa .

• Communication Channels
• visual visual

• Perception Channels
• visual visual
• tactile tactile
• chemical chemical

Food Habits

The larvae of the western populations of L. melissa eat a variety of legumes; Astralagus spp., Glycyrrhiza spp., Lotus spp., Lupinus spp., and Medicago spp.

The larvae of Karner Blue ( L. mellisa samuelis ) butterflies feed exclusively on wild lupine Lupinus perennis . Swengel (1995) found that the larvae seem to prefer lupine with larger leaves and longer, thicker stems. First and second instars chew tiny, circular holes in the leaves, and the third and fourth instars eat all but the upper or lower epidermis, leaving a window pane effect.

Adult Karner Blues have been observed nectaring on over 50 different species of flowers. They seem to select the nectar species with the greatest total number of flowers or flowering heads, usually yellow or white. Nectar species include Rock cress Arabis lyrata , lance-leaved coreopsis Coreopsis lanceolata , flowering spurge Euphorbia corollata , sweet clover Melilotus alba , horsemint Monarda punctata , common cinquefoil Potentilla simplex , raspberry Rubus spp., showy goldenrod Solidago speciosa , butterflyweed Asclepias tuberosa , and woodland sunflower Helianthus divaricatus . Males and females exhibit mud puddling behavior (sipping at moist earth) to obtain salts and minerals, and will sip human perspiration. Males have been observed feeding on animal droppings.

• Primary Diet
• herbivore herbivore
  • folivore folivore
  • nectarivore nectarivore

• Plant Foods
• leaves
• nectar

Predation

Known predators of Karner Blue larvae are primarily insects such as stink bugs , ants , and some wasps. Common parasitoids include tachinid flies and braconid and ichneumonid wasps. Common predators of adults are spiders, robber flies , ambush bugs , assassin bugs , and dragonflies . Though not documented, the absence of any reports of vertebrate predators may indicate some sort of anti-predator defense such as noxious smells or tastes, or toxins that are not tolerated by predators such as birds or mice.

Ecosystem Roles

Most butterfly species serve as pollinators to a variety of plant species upon which they nectar. Larvae of the Karner Blues have a mutualistic relationship with ants. Studies have shown that larvae tended by these ants have a higher survival rate, most likely due to protection by the ants against larval predators.

• Ecosystem Impact
• pollinates

Economic Importance for Humans: Positive

Due to the rarity of Karner Blue butterflies, there are potential human benefits in the form of ecotourism. Additionally, restoration and habitat management activities for this species enhance and protect unique ecosystems valuable for their beauty and ecological function.

• Positive Impacts
• ecotourism ecotourism
• research and education

Economic Importance for Humans: Negative

There are no known negative impacts to humans by Lycaeides melissa .

Conservation Status

Karner Blues were listed as federally endangered in 1992 due to losses in the eastern portions of their range. They are protected throughout their range, and many sites are actively managed. Karner blues are listed as threatened in the state of Michigan.

Other Comments

There are many common names for the various sub-species of Lycaeides melissa . Karner Blues have been called Orange-bordered Blue, and Edward's Blue; Melissa Blue has been named Orange-banded Blue, Orange-margined Blue, Orange-bordered Blue, Karner Blue, and Edward's Blue. They have also been placed in the genus Plebejus .

Additional Links

Encyclopedia of Life

BioKIDS Critter Catalog

Contributors

Ashley Dowling (editor), University of Michigan-Ann Arbor, George Hammond (editor), Animal Diversity Web.

Barb Barton (author), Special Contributors.

References

Dirig, A., D. Andow, R. Baker, C. Lane. 1994. Historical Notes on Wild Lupine and the Karner Blue Butterfly at the Albany Pine Bush, NY. Pp. 23-36 in Karner Blue Butterfly: A Symbol of a Vanishing Landscape . St. Paul, MN: University of Minnesota.

Glassberg, J. 1999. Butterflies Through Binoculars: the East . NY: Oxford University Press.

Grundel, R., N. Pavlovic, C. Sulzman. 1998. Habitat use by the endangered Karner blue butterfly in oak woodlands: the influence of canopy cover. Biological Conservation , 85: 47-53.

Grundel, R., N. Pavlovic, C. Sulzman. 1999. Nectar plant selection by the Karner blue butterfly <<Lycaeides melissa samuelis>> at the Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore. American Midland Naturalist , 44(1): 1-10.

Holland, W. 1931. The Butterfly Book . Garden City, NY: Doubleday, Doran and Co..

Iftner, D., J. Shuey, J. Calhoun. 1992. Butterflies and Skippers of Ohio . OH: Ohio Biological Survey Bulletin 9(1).

Maynard, C. 1891. Manual of North American Butterflies . Boston, MA: DeWolfe, Fiske, and Co..

Miller, J. 1992. The Common Names of North American Butterflies . Washington DC: Smithsonian Institute.

Miller, L., F. Brown. 1981. A Catalogue/Checklist of the Butterflies of America North of Mexico . FL: Lepidopterists' Society Memoir No. 2.

Neilsen, M. 1999. Michigan Butterflies and Skippers . East Lansing, MI:

Opler, P., G. Krizek. 1984. Butterflies East of the Great Plains . John Hopkins University Press.

Rabe, M. "Karner Blue Butterfly" (On-line ). Michigan Natural Features Inventory. Accessed 04/17/03 at http://web4.msue.msu.edu/mnfi/abstracts/zoology/lycaeides_melissa_samuelis.pdf .

Savignana, D. 1990. Field Investigations of a Facultative Mutualism Between <<Lycaeides melissa samuelis>> Nabokov (Lycaenidae), the Karner Blue Butterfly and Attendant Ants - PhD. Thesis . University of Texas.

Savignano, D., D. Andow, R. Baker, C. Lane. 1994. The Distribution of the Karner blue butterfly in Saratoga County, New York. Pp. 73-80 in Karner Blue Butterfly: A Symbol of a Vanishing Landscape . St. Paul, MN: University of Minnesota.

Scott, J. 1986. The Butterflies of North American: A Natural History and Field Guide . Standford, CA: Stanford University Press.

Struttmann, J. "<<Lycaeides melissa>>" (On-line ). Butterflies of North America. Accessed 04/17/03 at http://www.npwrc.usgs.gov/resource/distr/lepid/bflyusa/usa/252.htm .

Swengel, A. 1995. Observations of spring larvae of <<Lycaeides melissa samuelis>>. Great Lakes Entomologist , 28(2): 155-170.

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, 2003. "Karner Blue Butterfly" (On-line ). United State Fish and Wildlife Service. Accessed 04/17/03 at http://ecos.fws.gov/species_profile/species_profile.html?spcode=I00F .

Zimmer, D. "Nabokov's Butterflies" (On-line ). Accessed 04/17/03 at http://www.libraries.psu.edu/iasweb/nabokov/dzbutt4.htm .

Wisconsin Statewide Karner Blue Butterfly habitat Conservation Plan and Environmental Impact Statement. PUBL-SS-947-00. Madison, WI: Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources. 2000.